Helicobacter pylori in Alaska Natives: Difference between revisions

From Guide to YKHC Medical Practices

No edit summary
mNo edit summary
 
(29 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Helicobacter pylori is present in the stomach of the majority of adult Alaska Natives, with a similar prevalence in other circumpolar indigenous peoples. The high prevalance, high drug resistance rate, and high reinfection rate present unique challenges for management of Alaska Natives with upper GI symptoms.
Helicobacter pylori is present in the stomach of the majority of adult Alaska Natives, with a similar prevalence in other circumpolar indigenous peoples (such as in Canada, Greenland, Russia, etc). The high prevalance, high drug resistance rate, and high reinfection rate present unique challenges for management of Alaska Natives with dyspepsia symptoms.


==International Multi-disciplinary Working Group==
==Background==
In 2016 an international, multidisciplinary working group, including representative from the CDC Arctic Research Center and Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium, published an Expert Commentary<ref>McMahon BJ, Bruce MG, Koch A, et al. The diagnosis and treatment of Helicobacter pylori infection in Arctic regions with a high prevalence of infection: Expert Commentary. Epidemiology and Infection. 2016;144(2):225-233. doi:10.1017/S0950268815001181. [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4697284/pdf/S0950268815001181a.pdf '''Free PMC Article'''].</ref> which thoroughly reviewed the epidemiology, associated clinical syndromes, and treatment. Some of the key findings/recommendations are:
===Research===
A substantial amount of research has been published regarding this topic. As of October 2017, PubMed search for
[https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed?term=(alaska%5BTitle%5D%20OR%20polar%5BTitle%5D%20OR%20arctic%5BTitle%5D)%20AND%20helicobacter%5BTitle%5D <u>(alaska&#91;Title&#93; OR polar&#91;Title&#93; OR arctic&#91;Title&#93;) AND helicobacter&#91;Title&#93;]</u> returned 29 articles.  In June of 2016 researchers from the CDC presented Grand Rounds at YKHC and gave [[media:Hpylori Update.pdf|<u>this excellent talk</u>]] which summarized current knowledge.


* ''Screening or testing for H. pylori infection for the routine evaluation of dyspepsia or other gastrointestinal symptoms, whether utilizing serology, UBT or other techniques, is not clinically useful or supported by clinical evidence for high prevalence populations such as in the Arctic.''
===International Multi-Disciplinary Working Group===
 
In 2016 an international, multi-disciplinary working group, including representatives from the CDC Arctic Research Center and Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium, published an Expert Commentary<ref name=mcmahon2016>McMahon BJ, Bruce MG, Koch A, et al. The diagnosis and treatment of Helicobacter pylori infection in Arctic regions with a high prevalence of infection: Expert Commentary. Epidemiology and Infection. 2016;144(2):225-233. doi:10.1017/S0950268815001181. [https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4697284/pdf/S0950268815001181a.pdf '''Free PMC Article'''].</ref> which thoroughly reviews the epidemiology, associated clinical syndromes, diagnosis, and treatment of H. pylori in high prevalence populations. Some of the key findings/recommendations were:
* ''When treatment is employed, treatment should consist of regimens that have evidence of high efficacy after taking into consideration the antimicrobial resistance patterns in the region.
* The ''test-and-treat'' strategy (using serology, urea breath test, stool antigen test, other techniques) should ''not'' be used in high prevalence populations (such as in Alaska Natives).
''
* ''"When treatment is employed, treatment should consist of regimens that have evidence of high efficacy after taking into consideration the antimicrobial resistance patterns in the region."''
 
* Evidence supports treatment of H. pylori only in these situations:
* Evidence supports treatment of H. pylori in only these situations:
:# Duodenal ulcer
:# Duodenal ulcer
:# Gasgric ulcer
:# Gastric ulcer
:# MALT lymphoma
:# MALT lymphoma
* ''"When the goal is treatment of dyspepsia in patients from populations where H. pylori is highly prevalent, there is moderate evidence that H. pylori therapy should be undertaken only when there is endoscopic or histopathological confirmation of a condition associated with improvement following elimination of H. pylori, such as peptic ulcer disease."''


* ''When the goal is treatment of dyspepsia in patients from populations where H. pylori is highly prevalent, there is moderate evidence that H. pylori therapy should be undertaken only when there is endoscopic or histopathological confirmation of a condition associated with improvement following elimination of H. pylori, such as peptic ulcer disease.
Based upon these conclusions, the Working Group proposed the following algorithm for management of dyspepsia in high prevalence (>60%) populations (this includes Alaska Natives):
''
 
* ''There is insufficient evidenced-based data to support the H. pylori test-and-treat strategy in patients with non-specific dyspepsia.''


[[File:IWG Figure-1.jpg|500px|border|center|Algorithm for management of dyspepsia in regions with high prevalence (>60% population infected) of Helicobacter pylori infection.]]


Based upon these conclusions, the Working Group proposed the following algorithm for management of dyspepsia in high prevalence (>60%) populations:
===Controversies===
Evidence is equivocal regarding treatment of H. pylori in the setting of <u>severe</u> gastritis which is <u>not</u> associated with NSAID or EtOH use.<ref name=mcmahon2016/>  Please note that ''severe gastritis'' is an endoscopic diagnosis.  Endoscopists may differ in their management of this diagnosis.


===H. pylori Culture and Sensitivities===
H. pylori culture with sensitivities (from endoscopic biopsy specimens) is unavailable in most health care settings.  Fortunately, the CDC provides this service for rural, high prevalence Alaska communities, and YKHC participates in this program.  Results take 1 to 2 months, so a particular patient's results have little utility in treating his/her infection.  But population results inform the local <u>[[H. pylori Antibiogram]]</u> which should be utilized when prescribing H. pylori treatment.


[[File:IWG Figure-1.jpg|frame|center|Algorithm for management of dyspepsia in regions with high prevalence (>60% population infected) of Helicobacter pylori infection.]]
===Pediatric Considerations===
The management algorithm is the same for adult and pediatric patients. However, local pediatric EGD's are only available for teens who are essentially adult size.
<br>
<br>


==SUMMARY==
----
# '''Substantial research supports a different diagnostic and treatment algorithm for H. pylori in high prevalence populations.'''
# '''When dyspepsia fails to respond to a PPI, patients should be referred for EGD.'''
<br>
<br>


==YKHC/ANMC Helicobacter pylori Guideline==
===Resources===
In September 2017, the YKHC Medical Staff Executive Committee adopted/approved the ANMC H. pylori guideline, which is based upon the International Multi-Disciplinary Working Group findings and recommendations:
* CDC Slide Show[[media:Hpylori Update.pdf|''Updates on H. Pylori Research in Alaska 2016'']]
* [[media:H_pylori_dyspepsia.pdf|Dyspepsia (H. pylori) YKHC Clinical Guideline]]
<br>
<br>


==Treatment Guidelines==
===YKHC H. Pylori Treatment Guidelines===
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! Date !! Guideline !! Revision Notes !! Status
|-
| 04/26/2018 || [[File:H_pylori_dyspepsia.pdf|100px|Guideline]] || None || '''Active'''
|-
| 01/12/2022 ||  || [[H_Pylori_Guideline_Revision_Supplement_2022|2022 Revision Notes]] || Pending
|}
<br>
<br>


[[File:Guidelines2017 H-pylori.pdf|thumb|center|YKHC/ANMC Dyspepsia / Helicobacter pylori GUIDELINE]]
===ANMC H. Pylori Treatment Guidelines===
* Nov 2016 ([https://web.archive.org/web/20180107084913/http://anmc.org/files/CG_HelicobacterPyloriGuideline_010917.pdf Archive])<br>
* [https://anmc.org/files/CG_HelicobacterPyloriGuideline.pdf Feb 19, 2020 ]([https://web.archive.org/web/20201024034528/https://anmc.org/files/CG_HelicobacterPyloriGuideline.pdf Archive])<br>
<br>
<br>


[[:category:YKHC Guidelines|YKHC Clinical Guidelines]]
<br/>[[Practicing Medicine in Bush Alaska—Some ABCs|Common/Unique Medical Diagnoses]]
<br>
<br>


===References===
==References==
----

Latest revision as of 01:28, 13 January 2022

Helicobacter pylori is present in the stomach of the majority of adult Alaska Natives, with a similar prevalence in other circumpolar indigenous peoples (such as in Canada, Greenland, Russia, etc). The high prevalance, high drug resistance rate, and high reinfection rate present unique challenges for management of Alaska Natives with dyspepsia symptoms.

Background

Research

A substantial amount of research has been published regarding this topic. As of October 2017, PubMed search for (alaska[Title] OR polar[Title] OR arctic[Title]) AND helicobacter[Title] returned 29 articles. In June of 2016 researchers from the CDC presented Grand Rounds at YKHC and gave this excellent talk which summarized current knowledge.

International Multi-Disciplinary Working Group

In 2016 an international, multi-disciplinary working group, including representatives from the CDC Arctic Research Center and Alaska Native Tribal Health Consortium, published an Expert Commentary[1] which thoroughly reviews the epidemiology, associated clinical syndromes, diagnosis, and treatment of H. pylori in high prevalence populations. Some of the key findings/recommendations were:

  • The test-and-treat strategy (using serology, urea breath test, stool antigen test, other techniques) should not be used in high prevalence populations (such as in Alaska Natives).
  • "When treatment is employed, treatment should consist of regimens that have evidence of high efficacy after taking into consideration the antimicrobial resistance patterns in the region."
  • Evidence supports treatment of H. pylori only in these situations:
  1. Duodenal ulcer
  2. Gastric ulcer
  3. MALT lymphoma
  • "When the goal is treatment of dyspepsia in patients from populations where H. pylori is highly prevalent, there is moderate evidence that H. pylori therapy should be undertaken only when there is endoscopic or histopathological confirmation of a condition associated with improvement following elimination of H. pylori, such as peptic ulcer disease."

Based upon these conclusions, the Working Group proposed the following algorithm for management of dyspepsia in high prevalence (>60%) populations (this includes Alaska Natives):

Algorithm for management of dyspepsia in regions with high prevalence (>60% population infected) of Helicobacter pylori infection.

Controversies

Evidence is equivocal regarding treatment of H. pylori in the setting of severe gastritis which is not associated with NSAID or EtOH use.[1] Please note that severe gastritis is an endoscopic diagnosis. Endoscopists may differ in their management of this diagnosis.

H. pylori Culture and Sensitivities

H. pylori culture with sensitivities (from endoscopic biopsy specimens) is unavailable in most health care settings. Fortunately, the CDC provides this service for rural, high prevalence Alaska communities, and YKHC participates in this program. Results take 1 to 2 months, so a particular patient's results have little utility in treating his/her infection. But population results inform the local H. pylori Antibiogram which should be utilized when prescribing H. pylori treatment.

Pediatric Considerations

The management algorithm is the same for adult and pediatric patients. However, local pediatric EGD's are only available for teens who are essentially adult size.

SUMMARY


  1. Substantial research supports a different diagnostic and treatment algorithm for H. pylori in high prevalence populations.
  2. When dyspepsia fails to respond to a PPI, patients should be referred for EGD.



Resources



Treatment Guidelines

YKHC H. Pylori Treatment Guidelines

Date Guideline Revision Notes Status
04/26/2018 File:H pylori dyspepsia.pdf None Active
01/12/2022 2022 Revision Notes Pending



ANMC H. Pylori Treatment Guidelines



YKHC Clinical Guidelines
Common/Unique Medical Diagnoses

References


  1. 1.0 1.1 McMahon BJ, Bruce MG, Koch A, et al. The diagnosis and treatment of Helicobacter pylori infection in Arctic regions with a high prevalence of infection: Expert Commentary. Epidemiology and Infection. 2016;144(2):225-233. doi:10.1017/S0950268815001181. Free PMC Article.